The logic of piracy is economic, not romantic. Where expensive cargo moves along narrow routes and the cost of protection is high, predators appear. In the early 1700s Spanish treasure convoys funnelled silver, gold and emeralds through predictable choke-points such as the Windward Passage. Colonial navies were small, coasts were riddled with coves and the expected haul from a single capture could fund a lifetime. Buccaneering flourished until Europe stationed permanent squadrons and tightened insurance rules; only then did the “Golden Age” fade.

Three centuries on, the pattern is re-emerging—this time in sub-zero rather than tropical waters. Summer sea-ice in the Arctic has shrunk by about 40 % since satellite records began in 1979, opening channels that were once impassable. climate.gov  Russia’s Northern Sea Route (NSR) has become the main beneficiary: freight volumes rose from 3.7 m tonnes in 2014 to a record 38 m tonnes in 2024, a ten-fold jump in a decade. gcaptain.com  The NSR trims the Yokohama–Rotterdam run by roughly 4,000 nautical miles and, on paper, weeks of sailing time.

Cargoes are valuable—liquefied natural gas, battery metals from the Kola peninsula, even containers from east Asia—but escorts are scarce. Russia operates close to 40 ice-breakers, including a fleet of nuclear-powered giants. The United States must make do with three ageing cutters plus one second-hand purchase. nationaldefensemagazine.orgarcticportal.org  With hulls so thinly spread, large stretches of the Arctic Ocean resemble the Caribbean before Admiral Vernon: profitable, exposed and poorly policed.

Predators have already begun to test the gaps. Illegal, unreported and unregulated (IUU) fishing is spreading towards the pole. China’s distant-water fleet accounts for roughly 44 % of all visible global fishing activity and keeps thousands of vessels at sea for months on end. oceana.org  Recent monitoring reports describe “dark” ships—automatic identification systems switched off—hauling cod and crab on the margins of the Central Arctic Ocean. othjournal.com  The practice is lucrative: a single modern factory trawler can process and freeze 150 tonnes of fish per day, worth more than most Caribbean prizes of 1715.

Policymakers are not blind. Ten nations, including America, China and Russia, signed a 16-year moratorium on commercial fishing in the Central Arctic Ocean in 2018. arcticwwf.org  Yet a treaty is only ink; without cutters to board suspect vessels it risks becoming the era’s version of Spain’s ineffective asiento licences. Coast-guard budgets remain modest, and geopolitical friction over Ukraine distracts NATO navies from fish poachers and data thieves.

The economics invite further mischief. As ice recedes, insurers price in new “Arctic premia,” raising shipping costs; firms that forgo coverage gain an edge but assume greater risk, encouraging lightly regulated operators. The gap between rich cargoes and weak policing widens. Hijacking an LNG tanker would be harder than capturing a treasure bark, but cyber-raids on navigation systems or ransom threats to shore-side gas terminals could yield Caribbean-scale windfalls at lower physical risk.

History offers a sober lesson. Early intervention is cheaper than prolonged suppression. When Britain finally cracked down on Caribbean piracy it dispatched permanent naval patrols, established prize courts and hanged recidivists at Port Royal. The Arctic will need its own triad: more ice-class patrol ships, shared satellite surveillance and harsh penalties that bite across jurisdictions. Without them, the ghosts of Blackbeard and Calico Jack will sail under the aurora borealis, swapping cutlasses for GPS-spoofers and freezer holds.

Commerce follows the shortest route and so, inevitably, does crime. The world once learned that lesson in the balmy Caribbean. As the planet warms, it is learning it again in the chill of the North.

‍